Amish Schools

by Tammy Drennan

In the 1940s, the Amish did what the rest of us need to start putting more effort into: They largely withdrew from the public school system and created their own alternatives for education.

Public schools had begun to violate their principles on several fronts. Compulsory attendance ages were rising and subjects inimical to Amish ways were being advanced. And while religion is not actively taught in Amish schools (it is considered the responsibility of the home and church), it is important to them that their religious beliefs be reflected in how their children are taught:

“…in arithmetic, by accuracy and no cheating; in language, by learning to say what we mean; in history, by humanity; in health, by teaching cleanliness and thriftiness; in geography, by broadening one’s understanding of the world; in music, by singing praises to God; on the school grounds, by teaching honesty, respect, sincerity, humility, and the Golden Rule.” – The Amish School by Sara E. Fisher and Rachel K. Stahl

The Amish had enough sense to see that the public schools were not about to reverse course and bow to their standards. The logical reaction was to take matters into their own hands – which is, after all, the Amish way.

One advantage the Amish had is that they had not grown up in a culture of entitlement. They believe in self-reliance and do not regard it as a last recourse to be resented. They dug in, built school houses, found teachers, bought materials, established school boards and policies, and got on with the education and rearing of their children – on their terms, not the state’s terms.

Imagine if the rest of us were to embrace such an ethic. Imagine the beautiful culture and opportunities we could create for our children. Imagine how our children would feel seeing us taking control – acting like fully capable, in-charge parents.

How do you suppose our children feel when we shove them onto school buses or out our car doors in front of the local public school each morning; when they hear us ranting with friends and officials about what the state owes us in caring for them; when they come home from school suffering and lacking and we shove them out the door again the next morning?

We can do better by our children. They’re worth it. Ask the Amish.

6 Responses to Amish Schools

  1. Frances C says:

    Here, here. I admire the Amish for their willingness to stand for what they believe.

  2. Tim Larkin says:

    Great post! The Amish are an example to be followed. They are an example of how Americans can be free from government manipulation if they are willing to take responsibility.

  3. Jack Bouchard says:

    That kind of self-reliance is such an important, but rare quality in society. We are to reliant on the nanny state, something that is enforced in the public schools. The kind of thinking that is required to become an independent and confident individual is not developed, the prevalent view being that they are incapable of thinking in this way. From an early age this belief is presented to us, and so we are prevented from growing and developing.

  4. tdbwd says:


    Thanks much for your thoughts and observations. You’re so right — of all the things public schools rob kids of, self-reliance and self-direction are two of the most troubling. Your comment about it preventing us from growing and developing is something that has become very evident in society — where are all the grown-ups — people who know who they are, take personal responsibility, take action, run their own lives? It’s a sad state of affairs, but we can take back our children and our lives and turn the tide — I truly believe that.

    Again, thank you.


  5. Anonymous says:

    thanks for the great info. It helped a ton on the idenity of my anthropology project thanks so much again.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: